Welcome

Currently I work as a technician/ teaching assistant in the art and technology department at a secondary school in East London. Prior to this I studied at London College of Fashion (LCF) and Central St Martin’s (CSM). I have been working as an artist since my time at CSM, mainly doing commissioned work and working for small bespoke design companies and set up my own company called Not Quite Lauren last year. Over the last year I have decided that I would like to focus on becoming a teacher. Hopefully on completion of this course I will be able to do a Graduate teaching program (GTP).

Tuesday, 22 March 2011

How I plan to overcome the ethical issues surrounding conducting research in a school environment.

For this inquiry I plan to conduct interviews and perform case studies on students in my three chosen schools. In order to do this I will have to address a number of ethical issues which arise when dealing with minors. My first concern is getting parental consent.  In an article written by Danny Doyle entitled ‘Trans-Disciplinary Inquiry- Researching with rather then Researching on’ (2007) he outlines some of issues one might face conducting an inquiry such as this. In this article he speaks of a teacher/researcher who is trying to gain parental consent to question and interview her students as part of her research project. Initially consent was not granted as the parents could not see how by partaking in this research would benefit their child, all they saw was time being taken way from their education. Doyle suggested that had she aimed to obtain informed consent form the parent’s from the outset then she might not have received this initially scepticism from the parents. By informed consent I mean she should have explained to the parents in detail the purpose of the inquiry/investigation, give an outline of the content of the part of the inquiry that their children will be taking part in, and explain how the inquiry will benefit their child.
Doyle also suggests that to a certain extent the decision to be part of the inquiry should be left up to the student, if the student can be considered a ‘Gillick’[i]. The majority of the students I will be working with can be considered Gillicks but I am still going to seek parental consent as I am unsure how widely understood this concept is and I do not want parents complaining that I have not go through the proper procedures.  I plan to send letters out to the parents of each child I wish to use in my inquiry, giving a detailed description of what the child’s involvement will entail, how the inquiry will benefit their child, stressing to the parents that involvement in the inquiry will in no way impede on their school work and will take up minimal amount of their time.  This is a point that I plan to discuss with my employer and tutor because I do not want the students to think that I do not think that they are competent to make the decision themselves, as Masson said ‘Where children have the capacity to make a decision, parents’ power over that area of the child’s life is ended unless preserved by statute law. Consequently, a parent cannot consent to research on behalf of a competent child.’ (Masson, 2000 p.39) So at the moment I am in two minds as to what to do.  I believe that a number of the students can be considered competent and thus should be allowed to make the decision themselves but at the same time I do not want to get into any sort of altercation with parents because they think that i have not made them full aware of what is happening with regards to their children.   
I have decided that it will be best if all involved in the inquiry, the students, teachers and names of the schools remain anonymous. I think by doing this I will get rid of some of the confidentiality issues that might arise. It has been advised to me to do this by somebody who has recently underetaken a similar research project. This researcher chose not to do this and found that she was being constantly questioned by parents about the content and outcome of the interviews. By keeping all subjects anonymous the information gathered can be kept confidential until the inquiry is finished. I will of course be discussing elements of the inquiry with colleagues but this will be to get their feedback but as I will be working to a very tight schedule I want to ensure that all engagement in this inquiry will in some way add to it. As mentioned previously I plan to look at three contrasting art departments, gathering information from staff and students, I plan to give them factious names i.e. school x and pupil 2. Any questionnaires will be anonymous, distributed and collected in large numbers so that I will be unable to associate the answers with a particular person.  Another issue I am grappling with at present is how to keep the art departments anonymous. I will not use any names but because the three departments are so different it will be obvious which one I am talking about. At present I am unsure how to overcome this problem.  In his article Doyle using an outline set up by the NTRP, asks, and ‘is there a code of practice for the ethical conduct of research? Are there assurances about:
Whether the school and/or teachers will remain anonymous?
Whether the contribution of the school and the teachers is to be acknowledged and how?
How the data collection about teachers, teaching and learning or other aspects of school organisation are to be checked with those involved in generating them? For example will, teachers who are interviewed have access to records of the interview? Will the teachers or the school have a chance to comment on profiles draft questionnaires, proformas, interview schedules?
Whether the sample will target a range of teacher effectiveness and how is this to be defined. If so what will teachers need and want to know about how their work is being evaluated? Whether the teacher and/or the school have chance to comment on written outputs?
How disagreements about data or reports will be negotiated and reconciled? And whether there are proper arrangements for observing pupils and for parental permission? (NTRP, 2003)
I think this pretty clearly outlines a lot of the issues that I should mainly be considering, some of the questions I already have an answer to, some of which I am still considering, by having this outline I have a clearer idea of ethical areas for consideration when creating the inquiry proposal and conducting the inquiry. 


[i] ‘In 1986, the House of Lords decided in the case of Gillick V West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority that parental rights are not absolute rights. They are exercised by parents on behalf of children too young to exercise them for themselves. The case concerned a teenage child’s right to consent to medical treatment without the parents’ knowledge. Lord Fraser said that the degree of parental control varied according to the child’s understanding and intelligence.’  Danny Doyle ‘Trans-Disciplinary Inquiry- Researching with rather then Researching on’ (2007)

Tuesday, 15 March 2011

Ethical issues that have arisen as an art educator/educator in general:

The most important ethical issue I have encountered whilst working in a school environment is to have a strong understanding of child safeguarding policies, general ones that follow Government standards and the individual one that are put in place by the individual establishments. These policies are put in place not only to protect the students and their wellbeing but also to ensure that the members of staff do not put themselves in a position where they could be held liable in order to do this you should be aware of the child protection act and other such relevant legal documents. From a member of staff’s point of view you should conduct yourself at all times in a manner that is deemed to be appropriate. You are taught through staff meeting and inset days how to identify when a student is being bullied in school and what responsibilities you have to help the student and who you have to make aware of this. It is also the responsibility of staff members to be able to identify when a student is being abused at home or being neglected, again it is you have to know how to initially council the child and who need to be informed so that the student can get the necessary help. Not only is this your responsibility but if you do not you could be held liable. During school hours the teacher are put in a position of loco parentis, meaning at all times the teachers should have the student’s best interest in mind thus they should know what is included in legal documents such as the child safety act and equality act and have an understanding of health and safety and know all of your establishment’s policies. Not only are you there to protect the students but also monitor and as much as possible try to control the students behaviour while they are at school, this includes keeping track of their attendance, informing the correct people if it drops. In my opinion if there is anything you are in doubt about or unsure if it is something you should be dealing with, inform your superior.
  I have mentioned in previous blogs about the dangers the internet and other such web2.0 platforms pose to vulnerable parties in particular children, not only the content of what they might see but also how they can use them to exclude and victimise other students. In order to try and control this, staff members should have an understanding of how these technologies can be used. If you don’t understand what it is they are doing how can you expect to prevent it? Keeping up to date with technology is also vital in the teaching of all subjects. Teaching methods are constantly adapting to incorporate these technologies to improve the teaching of the subject.
Codes of Practice for teachers:
·     Be professional at all times.
·     Have a firm grasp of health and safety.
·     Be punctual at all times.
·    At all times behave in a way that you expect the students to behave.
·    Have an understanding of legal documents such as the Child Protection Act and all of your school’s safe guarding policies.
·    Keep up to date with advancements in technology not only how you can use them in the teaching of your subject but also how the students are using them.
·    Keep up to date with your course and what is happening within the industry in which you practice.
·    Be compassionate and sensitive when it is required.

Sunday, 13 March 2011

Ethical issues in the practice of art.

Whilst practising art these are some of the ethical issues that I have either been made aware of or have encounter whilst making my work. The major ethical issues I can think of all seams to steam from subject and material.
Materials:
 There has been much controversy over Marc Quinn’s sculpture ‘Self’ which is made of nine pints of his own frozen blood, a material which is commonly used by performance artists, but is it ethically acceptable to use bodily fluids as a material. Artists such as Jana Sterbak when she created ‘Flesh Dress’ or Dr Günter Von Hagen’s ‘Body Worlds’ exhibitions encountered similar problems.  Dr Von Hagen has actually been arrested on a number of occasions because of the materials he uses to create his pieces. If anybody is unfamiliar with his work, he uses corpses that have been donated for the development of science.   Bodily fluids and rotting meat have not been the only issues; Quinn’s work was in question again when he unveiled his gold sculpture of Kate Moss in 2008. May people questioned if it was right for him to create a sculpture which cost £1.5 million when the country is in a recession? In my inquiry I plan to try and encourage people to use unconventional materials in new ways and thus will have to think about all of these ethical issues very carefully.
 At CSM, when making work we were always encouraged to think about the sustainability of our pieces. How would the production/ creation of them impact the environment? Were there any ways that the piece could be made more environmentally friendly?
Subject:
The reader uses a good example, the Pulitzer winning photographer.  Should you intervene with your subject?  The Fashion industry struggles with this constantly, as a model if you are very thin then you will get work but where is the line between very thin and emaciated? As a designer/ photographer/ make-up artist is it your place to intervene when you are aware that if she were to put on weight she might loose work but if she didn’t she might make herself very ill.
Lucian Freud was often criticised for painting his daughters in a way that many deemed unacceptable, in his defence he didn’t paint them until they were adults and he claims that he uses the process of painting people to get to know them better.  So is it really unethical? One does have to be very careful when choosing a subject matter in particular when you are using human subjects.
Code of Practice for an Artist:
Each artist will come up with their own code of practice depending upon what setting they are working within but general guidelines to follow may include:
·        Having an understanding and sensitivity toward your subject.
·        Work in a professional manor
·        Try not to work in a vacuum, be aware of what other artist are doing.
·        Be accountable to your employer/ client.
·        Have an understanding of current political, economical and social activity.
·        To have patience.
·        To have an understanding of and sensitivity towards all cultures and religions. 

What are the ethical issues that I will have to take into consideration when proposing my inquiry topic?

        As my inquiry will involve a number of students some of which will be minors there are many ethical issues I will have to take into consideration. Namely the information that the students give me will have to be handled sensitively, in particular any personal information ensuring that confidential information remains confident and the students, parents and teachers are aware of what information will be published. Another issue that has been bothering me for a while is how it will be best for me to contact the students, in particular the students from my current school when they go off to different colleges. As I have mentioned before by law a teacher should not have any personal contact with previous students until they have been out of the school for at least two years. I really don’t want to put myself in a position where by my professional behaviour could be scrutinised thus I approached the art director with this issue. He suggested that I use email as my only form of communication, make sure that you don’t give any students my mobile phone number and ensure that I cc him and the student’s current art teacher into all of the emails. Also I must ensure that I have parental consent before I have any contact with the students outside of school. I think when dealing with minors one has to take a deontological approach to ethics. A set of rules must be established with no gray areas. It is either allowed or not. This is not the usual approach I would take to ethical issues in most cases I would consider myself a virtue ethicist. Believing that things are not black and white, the situation and the person’s character should be taken into account but sometimes subjectivity leads to confusion which you cannot have when dealing with minors and other vulnerable groups.
        Obviously before involving the students into any part of my inquiry I will have to get parental consent, I am slightly concerned about the possible parental involvement clearly they have the right to say they don’t want their children to answer certain question and know what information I am going to publish about their child but I really don’t want them getting too involved constantly peering over mine and their child’s shoulder censoring what they write and thus making the information I receive from them not as useful as it possibly could be. Again this is an issue that I have brought up with the art director as I didn’t really know how to approach this. His reply was there is not much I can do, if the parents decide that they want to be involved and check everything that is written then there is nothing I can do about it, I will just have to take this into account when analysing the information gathered. The only thing I can do to try and stop them from getting so involved is to give them no reason to feel like they need to be. Conduct myself and any interviews in a very professional way, be confident in what I am doing and ensue that I have an answer for every possible question that they might come up with. He suggested that if they feel confident and comfortable with me then they will not feel the need to scrutinise my every step.
        When I was looking into the ethical issues raised in the practice of art the main one was the materials used to create the piece. I listed some examples of occasions when materials have been used I what was considered an unethical way. This inquiry proposes to look into the use of materials and encourage active experimentation of materials in GCSE students and A-level. It is the reasonability of the educator to make them aware of the ethical issues behind using certain materials but as I will be looking into how they experiment with materials and processes in their work I will also ensure that they are aware of these facts. All of the ‘unethical’ materials mentioned in my previous blog will be out of the question for these students, not only because of the ethical implication but because school policy will not allow it, but they should be aware that these sort of issues should be taken into consideration when making their work to and extent now but more so later on in their artistic career.  
         The aim of this inquiry is to try and improve the teaching of art at GCSE and A-level. In order to improve it one must first identify the problems. When doing this I am going to have to be very careful not to offend any of the art teachers that I will be working with. At no point do I want them to think that I am criticising their teaching styles because who am I to tell them that they are doing something wrong?  I am not a teacher, I am not even a graduate yet, I am merely an observer and I will have to remember that is very easy to pick up on faults or areas for improvement when you do not actually have to do it. To overcome this problem I am going to try and be as involved as possible in the department I am going to investigate become involved in the classes and understand their dynamics so that if there are any criticism they know that they are well founded. I will also try to keep any areas for improvement very general, so that the comments do not appear to be aimed directly at any one teacher or department.
        Through doing this section of the module I have realised that there are many more ethical issues to be taken into consideration then I ever though. I was aware that dealing with children is an ethical mind field, but I was not aware of all the other issues. I am confident that there are still many more that I have not taken into consideration so if you read this and think of any very important ones I have missed please let me know.  I am also planning on scanning our schools child safe guarding document and up loading it as a pdf file obviously I will have to remove any sensitive information and details of the school but it might be useful for some of the other teachers who are not quite so familiar with safeguarding policies. Most of them are pretty standard for all schools. I will let you know where and when I have managed to upload it.

Monday, 7 March 2011

Award title rational

BA Professional Practice Fine Arts
I am aware that an award title like BAPP Art Education might seam like a more appropriate title in light of the topic I have proposed for my inquiry and the career path that I want to follow but I have only recently chosen to follow this path. Up until this point I have been and still am a practicing artist. I have spent over a decade refining my style and improving my skills and techniques. My choice to peruse a career in art education is just another page in my artistic story. The main reasons why I have chosen to focus more on the educational side art on this course is because I because this is an area where I have a lot to learn before I go on to do my teacher training and as the only fine artist on the course discussing teaching gives me a way to relate to the other students on the course.
                After leaving school where art was one of my A-levels I moved on to do my Foundation year in Fine Art at Leeds College of Art and Design. Two days into the course I was asked by Central St Martins (CSM) to interview for a place on a BA course (Art, Design and Environment) I was awarded the place but decided to defer it for a year as I had already started and paid for the Foundation course. I spent this year experimenting a lot with new techniques and processes and improving my core drawing and painting skills as I felt that this was the area I need the most improvement. I continued this exploration well into my time at CSM in the first year in particular I experimented with photography a lot, working with a process called liquid light. The second year I focused more on sculpture and looking at the relationship between materials and materiality.  During this period I was working a lot with metal. Unfortunately towards the end of my second year my financial situation changed and it became abundantly clear that I would be unable to complete my proposed projects for the third year. At this point I transferred to London College of Fashion (LCF) to study the first year of a BA costume design because an element of fashion had often been present in my work thus wanted to learn pattern cutting and manipulation and improve my seamstress skills while I had the chance (I was able to afford to do a first year on another course and not the third year on my existing course because the first year allows you a lot more free time to work).  Upon leaving LCF I did a lot of freelance and commissioned work including working as part of the creative team in an advertising agency.  In 2009 I set up my own business ‘Not Quite Lauren’. Initially it was intended to focus mainly on my fashion designs, in particular the design of formal and bridal wear but since the launch there have been as many orders for painting and sculptures as designs.
I am constantly creating new pieces not necessarily to sell but because art is my passion and will always continue to be.  For this reason and the fact that I have studied and explored the process of making art for much longer then I have studied the teaching of the subject rationalises my claim for my award title: BA Professional Practice, Fine Art.

Monday, 28 February 2011

Collegue's thoughts on my inquiry questions:

 Following the initial research I have done into my inquiry topic I thought now would be a good time to start to discuss some of these points with my colleagues.  I have spoken to the art director at the school that I am working at and my old art teacher (I am hoping to use their department as a comparative school in my inquiry).  They both seemed on board with the broader ideas of the inquiry but raised some logistical issues I might encounter, some of which I had already considered other I had not factored in at all and so am very glad I had these discussions with them. They also suggested possible ways around these problems which again I found very useful because they know much more about their schools policies and protocol then I do.
The first issue that was raised was if I want a student to participate in a case study whereby I track their progression from GCSE to A-level I will have to be very careful when selecting said student. I particularly noticed in the school that I work in it is hard enough to get the students to do their set work let alone optional extras where the benefit for them is not immediately obvious. To make the situation even more difficult we do not teach A-level in our school thus I will have to choose a student who is reliable and enthusiastic enough to get the work done with very little physical contact from me.  I will be relying almost entirely on web 2.0 technologies, but what are the ethical implications of this? I have previously blogged about INSET days where we have discussed child safeguarding and the school’s policies on contact with students outside of school. It is very clear; you are to have no contact with an existing or previous student until they have been out of the school for two years. The art director says that this doesn’t really apply to me because it would be for the purpose of research and not social interaction, but it is still something I will have to take into consideration.There is one yr 11 student who we think might fit these criteria from my current school, another option is to only get feedback from these students on the GCSE course and rely on students from the other school (who teach up to A-level) for the full case study. The only issue with this idea is I know the students at my current school and their work much better then I will know the students from the other schools and I wanted to see them reflecting in action and even more vitally get their reflections after they have finished. I would like to see how their opinions change after they have been faced with a harder challenge. I think at this stage they will be in a much stronger position to suggest what changes could be made to the teaching of the GCSE course.
One of the biggest issues when collecting data from individuals is the reliability of the information that they provide you with. What do I do if none of the feedback I get is useful? Or I have implied that some student find the transition from GCSE to A-level difficult, what if I find that this is not the case with any of the student if have chosen to use in my case study? Do I then rethink this part of the inquiry? If none of them struggle then they have been properly prepared for the next stage so what improvements could be made?  The art director at my current school has mentioned that the opposite is often the case with student from our school who go on to study art in local colleges. If anything they find themselves not stimulated. He explained that the reason for this is we have a very good art department and he pushes the students to work at a very high level particularly when it comes to commenting analytically on their work and the works of other artist. Other schools in the area don’t do this he suggests that they ‘spoon feed’ them through the course thus as a result the colleges have had to adapt their teaching style to cater for the majority. This means that our students who have come from an environment   where they are pushed and challenged to one where they are limited in the way that you work and thus quickly become unmotivated.  Another very important factor in this is, as an artist when working in an environment you are surrounded by people of an equal or higher level then you will constantly strive to improve, if not your work can very quickly become static.  So there is a strong possibility that the feedback that I get from my current year 11 students will be the opposite of what I initially thought, hence why I am contemplating looking at a third contrasting, a school that has the budget and facilities to be as good as the other two school but at present is not performing as well. The aim is that throughout the course of this inquiry I will identify possible reasons for why it is not as successful. It has also been suggested to me that I speak to the head of the art department at the local college where most of our student move onto.  Perhaps my investigation should also look at how the As-level/ A-level course tries to cater for this range of abilities and how successful they are. 
At this stage of my initial research I think it’s a good idea to possibly use a third school to investigate as it will give me more A-level students to engage with, which I think will help to answerer my art director’s question of why investigate the teaching of A-level when the school that I work in only teaches up to GCSE? The answer to this question is, because when I become a qualified as a teacher I want to teach A-level. The third comparative school will also help because I want to look into departmental budgets and how much effect the size of the budget has on the work produced by the student. My current school has a very small budget but gets very good results, The school that I attended has a large budget and very good results were as the third comparative school has a large budget but is not producing as high a standard of work as the other two. Does money make a difference? It would appear not but what effect would it have on the teachers and the work produced if the budgets were swapped? 
The question of whether or not a disproportionate amount of emphasis is put on academic subjects over creative arts was a question which he seemed very interested in and a topic that he has looked into himself. His suggestion was to look at the new British Baccalaureate system. Apparently in this the creative arts are no longer a mandatory part of the syllabus! In light of this I think my question has already been answered but I would like to find out why this is the case.

Tuesday, 15 February 2011

Now that I have put down and started to process all of my initial thoughts and questions about my chosen topic I am now going to try and group them into a number of broader questions, no more then 8 questions and try to explain how I think each smaller question fits into the broader one. By doing this I hope to give myself a better understanding of what I want to achieve from this research project and start to generate some ideas for a possible title and focal point.
How have I used such techniques as experimenting with materials and processes to improve my work?
How have I done this?

How does this further my understanding of the practice?

Explain and give examples of how I have experimented with techniques and materials and what do I think I have gained from this?

If I were to create a brief for a project based around the main areas of this research project what would it be?

Would it be beneficial to the project for me to complete this brief?

Where do I feel I sit within my professional practice at the out start of the project, do I think this might change if so how and why?

Are there any limits to this experimentation? Are there certain subjects or objects that are considered off limits, where the materiality of them cannot be altered? If so who brought about these parameters necessity or society?

How have other practitioners tried to approach this issue?

Artists who were considered to be part of the surrealist movement experimented a lot with using materials in an unconventional way. What did they hope achieve from this? Were they the pioneers of this concept? This area will be explored by looking at the works of specific artists?

How has this method of working influenced the way in which artists work now? To answer this question I will be looking at both artists and designers.

Can I see any of these influences in my work? If so where?

How does the work that I make inform my teaching of the subject?

What is the relationship between art and education and how does one feel about the other?

Raelin, 2008 suggests that ‘organic competencies constitute those that apply to particular jobs, and are specific to the context and language of the organisation.’ What are the possible organic competencies of teaching art and how do they differ from the practice of art?

I have often been advised to try and not become too comfortable within your own discipline, of course it will always be your preferred way of working but it is important to try and not let it encompass the way in which you teach and push the students into a direction that you want them to go rather than allowing them to arrive at a solution themselves. Do I think that this is true? If so what measures can be taken to try and avoid this from happening?
Eraut suggests that creating a map of professional knowledge will help to ‘illuminate the debate about theory- practice links and the role of experimental learning.’ This is one of the main areas that I want to explore in my investigation. How will I map my knowledge and define my knowledge base? Also could this technique be introduced to the students? Would it be beneficial for them? Last term i looked at learning cycles, could these ideas be incorporated to help to successfully map your knowledge?
I have previously mentioned in my blog that reflection has helped me work through difficult situations. I do I predict that I will use reflection to continue to improve my understanding and teaching of the subject. Does reflecting on the work that I make inform my teaching?  At the beginning of the year I decided to embark on the same project that the yr8 and 10’s were doing I hoped that this would give me a better understanding of what they were doing and thus put me in a better position to advise them, do I still feel that this has informed my teaching?

I have noticed that a lot of students struggle to make the transition between GCSE and A-level, what can we do as artist and art educators to try and bridge the gap and make the transition smoother?

What are the main issues the students are facing?
How do they feel teachers better prepare them for the more demanding A-level syllabus? I propose to use questionnaires and case studies of students to investigate these issues.

Does the school make that big a difference? I.e. state versus private, inner city versus rural. Obviously each school has a different budget of the art department, how much of an impact does this have on the teaching of the subject and consequently the work that the students produce?